Jump to content

Photo

Hearthfire reviews


  • Please log in to reply
99 replies to this topic

#1
Lingwei

Lingwei

    Old hand

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 502 posts
Hearthfire has been available for download on the Xbox 360 for several days now and some reviews have come in. The general theme seems to be 'good for a free afternoon' and 'not for everyone'.

Eurogamer:

What sort of Skyrim player are you? Are you there for the story and the Achievements, taking advantage of the game's loose logic to play multiple characters in one playthrough, heading up the Mage's College even as you take charge of the Thieves Guild, and saving the world while playing as an evil assassin? Or do you use Tamriel's vast canvas as a backdrop for your own adventure, setting your own limits and rules and immersing yourself in its rich milieu?

If it's the first then you've probably got no interest in Hearthfire, the new DLC that lets you build houses. There are no quests here, with no story and no definable ending. You may have already posted a witty comment about Skyrim Sims. Congratulations. Hearthfire is not for you.

If, on the other hand, you've already started planning which of your weapons you want to display where, whether to store gems in the same chest as jewellery, and are actually looking forward to spending hours trying to wrangle floating items into display cases so they're positioned just right, then Hearthfire is most definitely for you. It's just not that good.


Computer and Video Games:

It's totally bare inside, obviously. Building the house itself is only the beginning. You're going to have to source the rest of the materials yourself to build things like beds, cabinets, hearths, and sconces to light up the exterior. But remember, this is only the starter house. As you expand your property, it'll get much bigger. Your first house will become the entrance hall for a much grander one, and you'll get to add things like alchemy labs, trophy rooms, and libraries to store all the books you've collected on your journey. Because the plot of land creates a new fast travel point on the map, having your own self-contained base of operations is very useful.

There are three plots of land in all: one in Falkreath, one in Morthal, and one in Dawnstar. All three cost the same, and the only difference is the location; your house will always be in the same style no matter where you build it. You're also able to adopt children once your house is furnished. Constance Michel at the Riften orphanage (where Dark Brotherhood characters will have executed Grelod the Kind) will give you the chance to take one of the kids there back to your new home. You can adopt two at a time, and they get their own room.


There is no currently announced date or plans for the PC version. However, previous timed Xbox 360 exclusives have been made available for the PC approximately a month after initial release. Bethesda did not announce a release date for Dawnguard before making it available for PC, so the same may occur for Hearthfire.

#2
Rifli

Rifli

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 154 posts
It's kind of interesting that you can pick more than just one plot of land. I might pick it up.

Edited by Rifli, 07 September 2012 - 12:26 AM.


#3
BarnabasCollins

BarnabasCollins

    Journeyman

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 46 posts
I don't need another player home, but I'll probably download it just for the sake of encouraging Bethesda to keep cranking out official content; hopefully enjoyable content.

#4
Lingwei

Lingwei

    Old hand

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 502 posts

There are benefits to Hearthfire and serious role players will no doubt appreciate the improvement your hand-crafted homes offer over the default houses already available for purchase in the towns and cities.


Someone needs to explain to this reviewer the difference between LARPing and 'serious role playing'. FFS.

#5
potatochip

potatochip

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 167 posts
Finally, a place to live near Falkreath and the other holds without their own homes for sale.

That by itself is worth getting, let alone the ability to customize and develop the place yourself.

#6
joshx336

joshx336

    Faithful poster

  • Supporter
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,122 posts
Hearthfire just seems like something I'd set and enjoy after work with a few cold beers..Looking forward to it myself..I just hope the next DLC is something bigger like Dawnguard!!!


#7
DigitalPrinceX

DigitalPrinceX

    Fan

  • Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 392 posts
When it is available for pc, ill download it for supporting beth and hoping there will be even more interesting mods that utilizes the added resource/materials
The gameplay of hearthfire is not appealing to me

#8
rookie19

rookie19

    Enthusiast

  • Supporter
  • PipPip
  • 109 posts
Seems interesting so far, I'd like the adoption system.. then see what modders do with it.
COME JIMMY. TO THE SPIDER CAVE!

#9
FYI

FYI

    Enthusiast

  • Banned
  • PipPip
  • 115 posts

I don't need another player home, but I'll probably download it just for the sake of encouraging Bethesda to keep cranking out official content; hopefully enjoyable content.


Judging by this and other like comments here, devs sure do have any easy ride these days. When the sales figures role in for this "expansion", why would Bethesda be encouraged to put in the work to create anything more substantial when they can keep selling these!

#10
Proteus Draconis

Proteus Draconis

    Enthusiast

  • Members
  • PipPip
  • 118 posts
let's face it (although many of us already have): PC community is unimpressed and hard to please at this point because our mods are several months (sometimes years) ahead of bethesda. we see DLC's as giant modders resources that we immediately tailor to our liking. beth gives us some resources to play with, we run to nifskope, CK, and notepad++ and call it a day :">




Page loaded in: 1.221 seconds