Ok so update; I disabled everything but LINK, DarNified, the leveling mod, and alternate start since I wouldn't be able to test without a couple hours of work. New character each time, imperial race, battlemage and level up conjuration a lot; I still get only +5 to strength as my only modifier choice, everything else is +1. I'll see if verifying file integrity on steam will fix my issue; if not, I'll try to do a clean install of oblivion. Also Side Note, not sure if this matters but I have every Oblivion DLC. FrostCrag and all that other stuff, not just NoTN and Shivering Isles. Edit: So steam says files are fine, so I don't know anymore. Edit2: I'mma just go ahead and do the clean install, remove anything that could have gotten corrupted. I'll update with whether this worked or not for me.