I find the term "real gamers," unnecessarily divisive, but I'll answer nonetheless. I crashed through the 1000 hour barrier with Bethesda long ago - I don't bother keeping track any more. I've trekked through Arena, Daggerfall, Morrowind, Oblivion, and now Skyrim. Also, I've played maybe 300-400 hours of Fallout 3. I don't find any of Bethsoft's titles particularly challenging or innovative, but I enjoy them immensely. Skyrim feels like a step in the right direction, at least in terms of the series' evolution. When I step into Skyrim, I feel right at home. I recognize the play mechanisms, some of the voice actors, art direction, and even level design. It all feels rather organic. For others, those same characteristics scream "been there, done that." They find little to enjoy in the game. I'm enjoying the evolution of the game play in Bethsoft titles; glad I'm aboard for the ride. Based on your use of language in the post, seems like you came here hoping we'd convince you, or help you overcome your hesitation. I say — go with your gut! If you have doubts, trust your instincts. I don't think you'll like the game. Setting the graphics aside, Skyrim is only an incremental step or two above Oblivion. Based on what I've seen on the TES boards, many people who really dug Oblivion find themselves bored by Skyrim. You might consider skipping Skyrim, or borrowing a friend's copy when he or she is done with it. I love the game, and will probably spend hundreds of hours exploring it. Unfortunately, my personal enjoyment doesn't translate into anything meaningful regarding the experience of others. Whatever you decide, hope it works out well for you.