Oh, sorry. You can take Willow up with you and Victor doesn't care because the game only tracks the vanilla companions when it wants to do something about companions. If modders want to have something like it done with their companions then we have to do something about it. I've done nothing to Willow to include her in the checks that get done with the vanillas in the game. any idea what it could be if Sonia (modded companion) and Willow (those are the only 2 I have because I fired the other 2 I had) are both at home? am I a companion of myself? experimentally uninstall your mods in batches to find the offending item and how would I do that without causing corruption? you'll never know until you try. and the idea isn't to keep playing from these experiments the idea is to perform the experiments well, I figured it out 5 seconds after posting the last one: backups! and after disabling 2 of them, A wild new dialog option appears, player used mark save as success, it's super effective!