I've never found the All-American to be a strong gun. Especially for something requiring 100 skill and being so hard to get. It's basically a Ratslayer, without a silencer, with a bigger magazine, lower AP cost and higher spread. They should have given the All-American a silencer and 3 shot burst in VATS, just so it compete with things like the Gobi and COS Sniper Rifle. As for my top guns. LVL 1-15: Ratslayer LVL 15+ AER14 Prototype Q-35 Matter Modulator Gobi Scout Rifle Pacencia COS Sniper Rifle Forgot about the AER14, i love that gun. Anyway i thought i should mention that the the reason i like the All American so much is its versatility. Its not as acurate as the ratslayer but still fairly acurate for a 5.56mm gun and while not being very powerful per shot it has a high DPS. Also i should have mentioned that i use WME so i have a silencer for it :tongue: