BOS vs Enclave

[credomech]

Yeah, i really wish we could at least know where vault 1 is....but im brotherhood. they might be tech raiders, but at least they're not xenophobic genocidists (genociders?) hellbent on the destruction of all who are not them. a.k.a nazis. although i do like FNV Enclave, BOS all the way.

[PromiserOfDeath]

Both are Good and Bad

 

I really don't like Some of the The Views on Both sides.

 

Brotherhood of Steel

Pro: They want to Help People and Want to use the Water Purifier to Distribute Clean water to the People.

Cons: They want Technology and will kill anyone to get it.

 

Enclave

Pros: Return the World to the way it was before the Great War

Cons: They just want to kill everyone thats Infected and Mutated. Use the Water Purifier as a Weapon to Kill Everyone instead of Helping People.

 

 

Well 80% of the Planet is Infected so that leaves 10% Left that isn't Infected those being Vaults Dwellers that aren't exposed to the Outside world.

The Enclave are Infected just like the Rest of the World Because the Food and Water isn't Purified Yet. Except The Food and Water in Sealed Vaults and The Enclave don't Live in Sealed Vaults so they are Dooming themselves!

 

 

The Only 2 Good People in Fallout 3 are Harold/Bob and James.

[Moveing]

Remember Fallout Tactics where the Brotherhood runs labour camps? They are a bunch of very sick people.

[Nicknack644]

-First off im going to state that I have studied both Factions and I am NOT blindly taking a side.

-I will state Pros and Cons for both and use examples from the game. All facts are solid and researched.

-I have read almost all other comments and I am not taking a bias opinion on this topic.

 

The Brotherhood of Steel -

 

Pros: The BoS is a military oganization whos goals are to collect Technology to enshure that it doesnt fall back into the hands of those that might abuse it. (<--- Enclave)

I know that the original BoS is very obsessed with collecting Tech. but the CWBoS (Capital Wasteland Brotherhood of Steel) is trying to help the local population.

They have been protecting them for years even before the arrival of the Lone Wanderer. They defeated the Enclave and gave the waters of life to all. I Believe that

the BoS are the Best choice for the survival of mankind as a whole.

 

Cons: The Original BoS ( Ex. West Coast BoS) is very narrow minded to the fact that their main goal is to collect Tech. They mainly do not protect locals and will go to

crazy lengths to get the Tech. But like i said above, they collect the tech so that it DOES NOT fall into the hands of evil and begin what happened 200 years before.

 

The Enclave -

 

Pros: The living and breathing remnants of the United States of America. They represent the ideals of a lost Nation and will attempt to carry out these ideals to the death.

They have tech that the BoS didnt even know existed, like their every own type of power armor. The Mark II Power Armor (A.K.A Black Devil Power Armor) and more.

 

Cons: They Kill, and they Kill, and they Kill. The Encalve's foundations are bend on Killing. They even state this - They are to kill any and all mutated beings - and not just

super mutants or gouls, they seem to actually kill more HUMANS than any radiated thing! This to me is unacceptable. Each human being has their own thought, their own feelings, their own ideas, but the Enclave would wash all of them away in a attempt to have this 'Salvation'.

 

Conclusion: I will side with the Brotherhood of Steel on this one, but i have without a dought that if they were to have a peaceful conversion then perhaps they would indeed bring

peace and living to a wasteland riddled with radiation and desease. Like I said before though, they do both have their own flaws, some more than others, none are

perfect, but I am only taking who I think, and perhaps you, will lead the remaining humans to a better and brighter future.