I think the New York City idea would be great for Fallout 4, mostly because NYC is huge with lots of places that can be explored. But with it being so huge there wont be many outskirts, unless the bombs do some serious damage, so yes i'd like the NYC one better. Hopefully no matter what is choosen there will be more missions and weapons with harder monsters, the only real thing i liked on New Vegas was the way you snipe and hardcore mode. I really hope them two things come back.