GregariousJB

Yup, that worked. Thanks guys. The fix: Uncheck all notification options. Save changes. Check all notification options. Save changes.

Whaddya know, it worked, thanks. Now to see if I get notifications of mod comment replies. I've never seen one before. Could you (or someone) reply to one of my comments there to test it? The mod is long abandoned so no harm done. If this works, it'll mean re-checking notification options is a viable fix.

Been having the same problem since March. No email notifications to new replies in the mod I managed for a little while, and no email notifications to new replies to auto-followed topics I reply to. I only get email notifications for personal conversations (forum PMs). Nothing in my spam folder. My settings. I went through and unchecked all of the above settings, saved, then rechecked them and saved again. I'm hoping that'll fix something. Someone reply to this topic so I can test it.