In all intents and purposes, it's almost impossible not to side with him. Tarshana has a huge lack of understanding of how the law, copyright, and fair use works, which is unfortunate seeing as she had the potential to be a pretty solid mod author in the community. Suffice to say this won't go well for her, and it already isn't. I'm hearing people popping up one after another going, "Yo you hear about this psycho? False copyright striking stuff, jesus", and the sorts. And from what I've gathered, the mod in question that she filed a copyright strike on his video for isn't even majorly her original content(Something something she contributed 5% of the work), it's other people's content she simply ported over. The best we can hope for is that she at least got permission, or even at least gave credit pre-fiasco, so it would help her case a bit, but if it evidence ends up saying she failed to do both, then she's probly gonna get in a heap of trouble, be it by a community lynching, or the staff of the Nexus handling malignant users/modders. As much as I'd want to try to lean moderately on this situation, I'm too much of a proprietor of the first amendment, so it's increasingly hard to find a defense for Tarshana that isn't just blatant lies or biased information. Her signature on the forums is awfully ironic, too, seeing how she tried to silence someone's idea with a copyright strike. Like it or not, most folk, if not anyone, is at a right to criticize one another, be it their person or work, since criticism is the catalyst of change and improvement, especially if it's something being passed off as creative content. That is the very basis of the freedom of speech when in regards to critique and commentary. I'm personally just hoping that this doesn't turn into a Digital Homicide-gone-human incident. She may have acted foolishly, but she in no way whatsoever deserves threats of physical violence. Anyone that's doing that to her is going way too far and frankly are even worse than what Tarshana has been demonized as. MxR is also foolish for not listening to wishes of mod authors when asked. As much good as he brings to the community in the way of showcasing new mods, and the occasional niche mod, he should know by now that his relationship between him and the modding community is a two-way-street, and he's gotta look both ways if he's gonna cross the road, but he doesn't deserve a false copyright strike that directly affects his income, his livelihood, and his upload ability, especially from someone who doesn't understand how copyright works.