Steam Service Providers, and some how needing to clarify the Nexus stance again

[lobo3222]

In response to post #24663179. #24665119, #24665174, #24665184 are all replies on the same post.

digitaltrucker wrote:

DrGonzo31 wrote: Chesko? What happened there? o.O

WightMage wrote: He tried to pull all his mods from SW when the s#*! hit the fan... and was only then told by Valve's lawyer that they will not unless legally obligated to do so.

He was, by his own words, "beside myself with anger," because he felt that Arissa 2.0 was entirely his (and Griefmyst's) work.

Well, not anymore. And actually, this brings up another issue- if you upload a mod for sale on SW, and try to upload the exact same mod, same version and all, on Nexus, isn't that a clear Conflict of Interest? Furthermore, given how Valve legal responded to Chesko, it's highly likely that he will never be able to reupload Arissa 2.0 on Nexus or even his own website, since its no longer his property, if it ever was to begin with.

Let that be a warning to everyone who decides to deal with Valve/Bethesda: READ THE FINE PRINT.

digitaltrucker wrote:

explains it all.

lots...go to his site and read for yourself at http://www.nexusmods.com/skyrim/mods/11163/? and here

Edited April 26, 2015 by lobo3222

[diyeath]

In response to post #24662889. #24662979, #24663134, #24664289, #24664594, #24664599 are all replies on the same post.

Brumbek wrote:

digitaltrucker wrote: ...and another one goes. Good luck...

Ventry wrote: If the free version here and the SW version are one and the same.
Then you have my support and best wishes and perhaps donation.
However if SW version has content that the free version here does not then that's a different kettle of fish altogether.

lelouch107 wrote: He posted on his page that the most up to date version will alwaysbe free on nexus..only steam version charges for 'convenience'. Honestly I'm ok with that model.

WightMage wrote: Just keep in mind that once its on Steam, you will not be able to remove it unless Valve is pressured legally. You should read the fine print and make sure you're allowed to have the same version of both mods in two different locations.

phantompally76 wrote: That's very unfortunate. Was hoping you wouldn't buy into this Ponzi scheme.

Nothing personal Brumbek, as stated earlier, I like SMIM. But I will be unendorsing and uninstalling it and using texture mods from non-paywall authors. No offense intended to you, and I wish you the best of luck in your quest for money.

Well considering you're keeping SMIM up on nexus I see no issue with that. Kinda self-defeating though, anyone worth their salt knows about this site and will see its free here.

If your goal is to drive traffic away from steam you very well might accomplish your goal as they'll come here and see the mod for free. Edited April 26, 2015 by diyeath

[Ryker61]

In response to post #24663854. #24664244, #24664334, #24664879, #24665094, #24665224 are all replies on the same post.

Ryker61 wrote:

WightMage wrote: Sauce?

Who filed it? Was it another modder?

Will we need to backup our versions of Wet & Cold before the take down notices appear here?

WightMage wrote: Oh my God: https://archive.is/ayjaw

Regardless of my personal feelings regarding Isoku, this really sucks.

Ryker61 wrote: I took a screen cap of his W&C SW page, but I have no way of posting it here. You'll have to go and check it for yourself.

The notification is at the top of the page. There's no indication as to the identity of the individual who filed the DMCA.

I highly doubt a DMCA will be filed here on the Nexus. My suspicion is that the DMCA was filed over recent paid mod fiasco.

DrGonzo31 wrote: I'm guessing it wasn't actually the mod author who uploaded that for sale, but some jagoff looking to make money off someone else's work. That's really my big fear here: what's to stop someone from taking someone else's mod and selling it on steam? Maybe because I don't use the Workshop there's a few pieces I'm missing, but that's what I see causing the whole thing to go pear shaped.

WightMage wrote: No dude, that was totally Isoku himself who uploaded Wet and Cold. The only problem is, like Chesko, he forgit that most of his work uses assets made by OTHER modders to begin with, for free.

More likely than not, one of them filed that DMCA.

While that sounds like a good theory, I'm a little skeptical as to whether or not that is the case. We'll have to wait and see.

The other side of it is that if that is the case, and someone fraudulently uploaded Isoku's mod, then why hasn't he come forward to let everyone know that this happened?

Edit: Wrightmage replied before I did. Edited April 26, 2015 by Ryker61

[Deleted3507349User]

In response to post #24663854. #24664244, #24664334, #24664879, #24665094, #24665224, #24665344 are all replies on the same post.

Ryker61 wrote:

WightMage wrote: Sauce?

Who filed it? Was it another modder?

Will we need to backup our versions of Wet & Cold before the take down notices appear here?

WightMage wrote: Oh my God: https://archive.is/ayjaw

Regardless of my personal feelings regarding Isoku, this really sucks.

Ryker61 wrote: I took a screen cap of his W&C SW page, but I have no way of posting it here. You'll have to go and check it for yourself.

The notification is at the top of the page. There's no indication as to the identity of the individual who filed the DMCA.

I highly doubt a DMCA will be filed here on the Nexus. My suspicion is that the DMCA was filed over recent paid mod fiasco.

DrGonzo31 wrote: I'm guessing it wasn't actually the mod author who uploaded that for sale, but some jagoff looking to make money off someone else's work. That's really my big fear here: what's to stop someone from taking someone else's mod and selling it on steam? Maybe because I don't use the Workshop there's a few pieces I'm missing, but that's what I see causing the whole thing to go pear shaped.

WightMage wrote: No dude, that was totally Isoku himself who uploaded Wet and Cold. The only problem is, like Chesko, he forgit that most of his work uses assets made by OTHER modders to begin with, for free.

More likely than not, one of them filed that DMCA.

Ryker61 wrote: While that sounds like a good theory, I'm a little skeptical as to whether or not that is the case. We'll have to wait and see.

The other side of it is that if that is the case, and someone fraudulently uploaded Isoku's mod, then why hasn't he come forward to let everyone know that this happened?

Edit: Wrightmage replied before I did.

Of course, we have no way of knowing if the DMCA takedown notice is itself legitimate.

[WightMage]

In response to post #24663854. #24664244, #24664334, #24664879, #24665094, #24665224, #24665344, #24665379 are all replies on the same post.

Ryker61 wrote:

WightMage wrote: Sauce?

Who filed it? Was it another modder?

Will we need to backup our versions of Wet & Cold before the take down notices appear here?

WightMage wrote: Oh my God: https://archive.is/ayjaw

Regardless of my personal feelings regarding Isoku, this really sucks.

Ryker61 wrote: I took a screen cap of his W&C SW page, but I have no way of posting it here. You'll have to go and check it for yourself.

The notification is at the top of the page. There's no indication as to the identity of the individual who filed the DMCA.

I highly doubt a DMCA will be filed here on the Nexus. My suspicion is that the DMCA was filed over recent paid mod fiasco.

DrGonzo31 wrote: I'm guessing it wasn't actually the mod author who uploaded that for sale, but some jagoff looking to make money off someone else's work. That's really my big fear here: what's to stop someone from taking someone else's mod and selling it on steam? Maybe because I don't use the Workshop there's a few pieces I'm missing, but that's what I see causing the whole thing to go pear shaped.

WightMage wrote: No dude, that was totally Isoku himself who uploaded Wet and Cold. The only problem is, like Chesko, he forgit that most of his work uses assets made by OTHER modders to begin with, for free.

More likely than not, one of them filed that DMCA.

Ryker61 wrote: While that sounds like a good theory, I'm a little skeptical as to whether or not that is the case. We'll have to wait and see.

The other side of it is that if that is the case, and someone fraudulently uploaded Isoku's mod, then why hasn't he come forward to let everyone know that this happened?

Edit: Wrightmage replied before I did.

digitaltrucker wrote: Of course, we have no way of knowing if the DMCA takedown notice is itself legitimate.

Isoku left the Nexus two days ago, when the paid mod scheme launched. He said as much in a goodbye post here in one of the mod comment sections- either Wet and Cold or iNeeds.

[Deleted3507349User]

[Honkstar82]

Just wanted to say thanks for the update, Dark0ne. I've been a long-time lurker on this site, and the Nexus has always been a great place to find cool mods. Also, this bit:

 

"The finger pointing has begun. Pointing the finger at Valve, at Bethesda, at modders, at the Nexus, at YouTubers. Have you really not seen this coming, at all? Evolve launching with $100 worth of day zero DLC? Buying games knowing the developers have said they won't release SDK's any more because it's "too hard"? Paying money to beta test games in Early Access? Pre-ordering games based on hype despite the developers and publishers enacting review embargoes? Users spending $220 million plus on mods already for TF2, CSGO and DotA 2? Of course this was coming. Anyone who's done any of these things has been complicit in getting us to this stage! I'll put my hand up and admit I bought DayZ stand-alone. I'm sorry, alright, I didn't realise they were going to be this bad and take this long!"

 

You've got it by the hilt, sir. This has been a long time coming, and the signs have been clear. I don't want to see all mods for any game "DRM-locked" to a service like Steam. The whole point of mods is that they're community efforts, independent of the developers' imprimatur. Rewarding mod authors is well and good, but why should a company like Bethesda take a fat cut when they're not putting in any additional effort and leaving the mod maker on the hook for all support? That sounds a lot like the no-effort and day-one DLCs that are pushed out more and more these days. Another company trying to make fat stacks of money without doing any actual work, instead of producing a quality product and offering it on the open market.

 

Just wanted to say thanks. I've enjoyed the use of your Nexus for many years. You ain't a "poster-child", but you are trenched deep into solid facts and speakin' sense. Here's hoping that modding as a hobby continues for a good, long time. Also, get a nap when you can!

[Deleted3507349User]

In response to post #24665434.

digitaltrucker wrote:

...yes, I deliberately chose this version. Compare the actual artist and the people in the video.

[zanity]

In response to post #24663179. #24665119, #24665174, #24665184, #24665254 are all replies on the same post.

digitaltrucker wrote:

DrGonzo31 wrote: Chesko? What happened there? o.O

WightMage wrote: He tried to pull all his mods from SW when the s#*! hit the fan... and was only then told by Valve's lawyer that they will not unless legally obligated to do so.

He was, by his own words, "beside myself with anger," because he felt that Arissa 2.0 was entirely his (and Griefmyst's) work.

Well, not anymore. And actually, this brings up another issue- if you upload a mod for sale on SW, and try to upload the exact same mod, same version and all, on Nexus, isn't that a clear Conflict of Interest? Furthermore, given how Valve legal responded to Chesko, it's highly likely that he will never be able to reupload Arissa 2.0 on Nexus or even his own website, since its no longer his property, if it ever was to begin with.

Let that be a warning to everyone who decides to deal with Valve/Bethesda: READ THE FINE PRINT.

digitaltrucker wrote:

explains it all.

lobo3222 wrote: lots...go to his site and read for yourself at http://www.nexusmods.com/skyrim/mods/11163/? and here

What are you dribbling about? Valve and Zenimax can write anything they like into EULAs or other agreements, and those agreements hold no more weight in Law than this morning's flushed toilet paper if Valve and Zenimax seek to restrict your rights.

Let me make this SIMPLE. say you release code under some open-source licence. Then you SELL your code under a different licence (which as the code owner you are most certainly entitled to do). The fact that you now sell your code (or someone sells it for you) CANNOT terminate the earlier open-source licence. Idiots that no NOTHING about the Law constantly claim that a new license can over-ride an old existing one.

What about a mod that has never been published anywhere before it appears on Steam Store. Even here, the attempt by Valve to claim EXCLUSIVE distribution rights wouldn't stand up in court. For Valve to earn such a right, it would have to be providing a significant SERVICE to the mod creator, else it would count as RESTRAINT OF TRADE. Merely offering a shop front isn't good enough.

Valve has always attempted to act beyond the Law, claiming (falsely) that its business model is not covered by existing consumer and fair trading Laws. Valve pays off complainants BEFORE they seek legal redress in court, to hide the fact that most of their terms and conditions are illegal- certainly throughout the EU. The fact that Valve actually told mod authors to freely pirate each others content should come as no surprise whatsoever.

Anyway, it is Zenimax that has been most despicable- waiting until the modding community for Skyrim was ready for HARVEST, so an insanely immoral corporation (remember- it claims that Oculus Rift VR is theirs simply because they allowed Carmack to work there) could make a few extra dollars.

Any decent company would have left Skyrim alone (after all this time) and kept the new 'feature' of paid mods for Fallout 4, where a fresh start could have at least attempted to address all the potential issues. Edited April 26, 2015 by zanity

[yvonneka]

In response to post #24646984. #24647104, #24647439, #24647524, #24647569, #24647954, #24648029, #24648264, #24648309, #24648414, #24648504, #24648519, #24648809, #24649619, #24650179, #24650239, #24650354, #24651039, #24651229, #24651294, #24651314, #24651324, #24651364, #24651429, #24651469, #24651679, #24651784, #24651844, #24651864, #24651949, #24652074, #24652084, #24652114, #24652274, #24652374, #24652484, #24652614, #24652634, #24652709, #24652984, #24652989, #24653374, #24654079, #24654169, #24654569, #24654739, #24654814, #24654864, #24654924, #24654954, #24655019, #24655324, #24655564, #24655599, #24655739, #24656204, #24656864, #24657599, #24657739, #24657834, #24658089, #24658219, #24658309, #24658354, #24658389, #24658469, #24658654, #24658804, #24661294, #24661744, #24661969, #24662334, #24662424, #24662559, #24662704, #24662874, #24662989, #24663029, #24663049, #24663124, #24663129, #24663169, #24663709 are all replies on the same post.

Psijonica wrote:

SchwererGustav wrote: This post wwll be deleted in...3...2...1...

You will see ;)

bigdeano89 wrote: Way to sound like an entitled 12 year old man. Dark0ne has been honest from the start. Good luck trying to find another site btw, all the others are either gone or ALSO took the service provider option. That includes AFKmods etc.

Dark0ne is not the only site to do that, so stop making them out to be the bad guys. Nexus has been around for years giving mod authors FREE space for mods big and small.

Dark0ne wrote:

As you paint yourself as the saviour of the free modding community

This post wwll be deleted in...3...2...1...

Why would I delete it? It's a perfect example of the people who don't actually read what I write and, in the process, make themselves look stupid.

SchwererGustav wrote: Because 2 of my comments got delleted befor...

The 1st was a bit aggressive the 2nd not at all.

rotwhip wrote: ooooh someone is angry.

Psijonica wrote: I read what you wrote and I can only giggle that you have lowered yourself to calling me "stupid" LoL

You can fool all the kids here but anyone with real business and life experience sees right through you.

If I am stupid because I don't take your words at face value then so be it... I am a stupid person who drives a Super Snake and I am laughing at how stupid you may think I am.

Basically you are still supporting Pay-for-Mods just that you are calling it by a different name. Many modders like Emma (I guess you think she is stup[id too now eh? Remember her, yoiur old friend who helped you with your uploaded system all thiose years ago?) also believe that this is wrong in every aspect... but I guess we are just stupid.

I can't really tell youwhat I think of you because hey, I'm in an unfair possition where you are able to swing insults but I can't.

Congratulations! *Applause*

benissugger wrote: he said you "make yourself[es] look stupid", not "you are stupid".

JoeyLock wrote: So basically Psijonica, you're saying "Stop asking me for money! Dark0ne just pay the $500,000 to run this community per year and deal with it!" yes? Think about that statement, Endorsements, Permissions and Donations are the very things that keep this community and these mods afloat, if you want 100% free mods, make them all yourself and pay for the site to upload them on.

twhelan wrote: We must excuse those who cannot understand the context of a single sentence.

WightMage wrote: What does Emma, creator of Vilja, have anything to do with this?

Dark0ne wrote: You started with, in response to my article:

As you paint yourself as the saviour of the free modding community

I've already written:

If people are heralding me, specifically, as their champion in the fight against paid modding then they've done that of their own accord, and I certainly haven't agreed to be that champion....Does this sound like a champion of modding being free everywhere? No, it does not. Do not use me as the poster-child for that campaign as I never said I was.

So you either didn't read it, or you read it, and then decided to say I was painting myself as the "saviour of the free modding community" when I've specifically said I neither am or want to have that title. So yes, you look stupid. Even more so, now.

HadToRegister wrote:

Psijonica

Am I going to close all my account? No, not yet. But as soon as there is an alternative choice you can bet I will choose it.

I'm sure that threatening to close your FREE Nexus account that you pay NOTHING for, has most of the people at The Nexus quaking in their boots.

seversky wrote: Psijonica, you are an incredibly spoiled little child. Go away please. Don't come back.

phantompally76 wrote: I don't think Psijonica "looks stupid" at all, Dark0ne.

Quite the opposite, actually.

And I also think that YOU are coming out of this looking dishonest, petty, unapologetic, and at the risk of upsetting you (which is not my intention), just a little sociopathic.

You can't shrug or laugh this off. This is a MUCH bigger deal than you're trying to make it out to be, and just because you refuse to admit there is a problem with your lack of disclosure and transparancy....that doesn't make the problem go away.

And like it or not, a LOT of people have a problem with this.

Reaper0021 wrote: There is no "Bigger Deal". All of it was blatantly obvious, in the open and known by those of us that bothered to read it. These attacks are starting to get pretty damn pathetic. There was/is no conspiracy nor big deals made that have betrayed anyone.

TKHBMVP wrote: From my community experiences in the early 90ies until now on several forums and when usnet newsgroups support forums started remembering from the past, nothing has changed so far with the participants and their communication habbits ;-) It is still the same.
But when I read across all of this thread I'm happy that a lot of people making up their mind on this topic and thinking about the different point of views of the involved people.
Finally this proved that Nexus has a great audience and value modders and members sharing a most valuable content.

Psijonica wrote: YaY! You called me stupid twice! HAHAHA ;D The fact that you keep commenting says more than you know. it says that you feel you need to bully me in order to distract people from the real issue whisch is that you are in one hand holding up a protest sign while with the other taking payments from the people you are saying you are protesting against.

I have to laugh at you.But I guess I'm just stupid or maybe that the throngs of people who once used to get mods for free are now much smarter than me now that they will be paying for them eh?

*SIGH* Look at his last words, "That is what I will fight. That is what I will champion against." and tell me that he is not proclaiming himself as the white knight LoL

and to those of you who say he is not making money, please who are you fooling... he is raking it in and he is only here instead of on vacation trying to protect his money.

joeriz9 wrote: Keep it up kiddo, Good way to get yourself banned by not reading anything that has actually been said.

Reaper0021 wrote: Why are you even posting Psijonica? I mean what's the point you're trying to make beyond just annoying the staff? He was transparent about this whole thing to begin with. There is no hidden agenda. It was publicly posted and I read it before it was brought up by a member who found it the same way I did: Just looked and it was there. It wasn't 'hidden' and wasn't an attempt to be deceptive.

locomotive1236 wrote: "YaY! You called me stupid twice! HAHAHA The fact that you keep commenting says more than you know. it says that you feel you need to bully me in order to distract people from the real issue whisch is that you are in one hand holding up a protest sign while with the other taking payments from the people you are saying you are protesting against.

I have to laugh at you.But I guess I'm just stupid or maybe that the throngs of people who once used to get mods for free are now much smarter than me now that they will be paying for them eh?"

If you consider that bullying, I'm not sure what world you live in. As I understand it from his posts, he's staying neutral at the moment because he understands both sides. I also do not see any point of arguing with someone who is incapable of see things from only one perspective and have such a fragile self-esteem.

MCato wrote: "As you paint yourself as the saviour of the free modding community you are not fooling me"
===
Please show me any of your mods, even the smallest. Then I'll take your words seriously

HadToRegister wrote:

Psijonica
YaY! You called me stupid twice!

Actually, no he didn't, what you HAVE done though, is shown that twice now, you lack any reading comprehension skills whatsoever, which also explains why you have the whole Valve/Nexus thing so wrong.

Because you read and then interpret everything the way you WANT it to be, rather than the way it actually IS, facts be damned.

SchwererGustav wrote: It's a joke really , anybody with a brain can see were this is going and it is definitely not going to be good for modders who do it for the love of modding and not for the shekkels.

The corps and shareholders will love this news, alot of people (with alot of money) will make a quick buck and leave the modding community in the dirt.

But who are we to judge we don't have a shitload of servers that the community payd for...

Reaper0021 wrote: Had is right. Your a stone-headed kid that's got a conspiracy theory to play with and I'll be damned if your immature ass isn't going to play with it. You just refuse to read and comprehend what's written or you see ulterior motives abounding in everything people say and do.

sunshinenbrick wrote: I hope I don't regret bringing this point up. We are entitled to opinions are we not? And we are allowed to doubt what people say at face value, are we not? That is part of a community and it does not help to throw insults at one another, even if it's understandable as we all have a lot of passion about modding.

gingersnapples wrote: you sir are a clever troll, or wear lead-lined hats on a daily basis. can't decide which.

oh well. time ever flows onward, and this, too, shall pass.

ZeroKing wrote: Yeah! Community effort, guys! We get stuff for free, we'll give no support for the effort here, and we demand retribution for what the site owner believes in because he has to pay for the servers..... oh wait.

I forgot about the $500,000 annual server cost that most of us contribute next to nothing for. Yeah, reality sucks, eh?

Reaper0021 wrote: Yes your opinions are indeed welcome. This person isn't stating an "Opinion" this person has taken facts, mixed them up into his/her own little theory, and is attacking Dark0ne. Best if you don't get involved in it as you too seem to not know whats going on either. ****I'm giving you Kudos Zero cause I haven't seen you in so long.

Psijonica wrote: No reaper he has not been honest at all. When explain your self and leave out certain elements then that is being dishonest.

Let's face it, the reason he is saying is is neutral is because he is afraid to actually state his position. Wishy washy... and because I have an opposite opinion of how he has handled this now everybody trolls me. LoL Like I care. I own my house (paid for) and have a wife who loves me and 3 children that I feed and clothe and I am here with my eldest fighting for what I believe is right.

I believer he has lied, I believe he is not being honest and I don't trust his so called good intentions.

I can not believe for the life of me what is happening and you know what, if this goes through then this whole generation deserves SOPA and all the other corporations to come in take over the internet.

Of course I say that with tongue in cheek but I have been fighting the machine my whole life and I am getting tired... this really makes me not want to care any more and just let the children work it out themselves.

Pay-for-mods is the absolute worst thing that can happen and it is pretty much a done deal.

If Dark0ne want to be the Champion then let him refund all the money he gets from valve directly to the moddders. Lets see if he does that eh?

ZeroKing wrote: PhD in biomedical engineering, have a wife and 6 children. Disabled from the waist down, and still work across 17 countries annually.

Doesn't pay Robin's server bills with my personal morals and my credentials, does it?

Reaper0021 wrote: "Pay for mods" is a bad idea. I'm 44, own 4 houses (live in one rent the others 3 small houses to help my disability) and have 1 child...no wife. And? The make-up of my family or my residence doesn't validate my words any more than it does yours. He isn't betraying us. It was always there to see...I know I read it. I'm sorry this has all happened to turn this community on it's damned head. I've seen you posting in forums before and you are one smart guy. You really are. I've enjoyed your input in the past and it's hard for me to see you being this willfully stubborn.

sunshinenbrick wrote: Ha, thank you... I think :/ I have never considered myself a troll (only learnt what it was a couple of year ago...) being a bit of old fashioned.

I just think it can be unwise to just use the arguement that "it's just the way it is". But I also think there can be constructive ways to talk about this. As in trying to organise a way of reducing this "slippery slope" that has been mentioned a number of times. And I wanted to suggest that getting hissy with each other is not going to help... perhaps that what was predicted to happen??

benjaminpen wrote: Are you drunk? No, seriously... Are you? You seem a little incoherent to me.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I see no conflict between the following two statements:
"I WILL NOT fight someone's right to charge for mods on ANOTHER site. It is NOT okay to charge for mods on THIS site."
"I WILL fight anyone who says I don't have the right to NOT CHARGE for mods on MY site."

And no, I don't think that mod authors being able to donate some of the money being made to the Nexus is a conflict either.

edit: He didn't get the money from the modders' cut, he got it from Valve's cut.

Reaper0021 wrote: Your right Sunshine maybe that's what I needed to calm down was an impartial 3rd to say something. Yeah I'm going to let this rest for now. Try again tomorrow I think. Peace to you all and Kudos to Sunshinenbrick.

HadToRegister wrote:

Psijonica

I own my house (paid for) and have a wife who loves me and 3 children that I feed and clothe and I am here with my eldest fighting for what I believe is right.

Yet here you are, complaining about seeing advertisements on your FREE account.
If you actually HAD all of that stuff, and were mature, you wouldn't need to list ANY of that, as it has NOTHING to do with your conspiracy theory.

Psijonica
If Dark0ne want to be the Champion then let him refund all the money he gets from valve directly to the moddders. Lets see if he does that eh?

Hey, let's see you contribute to the $500,000 annual upkeep for the nexus THAT YOU USE FOR FREE.
You're using a website for FREE and demanding that someone else PAY for something that has already been explained, that all of us adults were able to comprehend quite clearly on our first read-through of Robin's article.
At this point, I can only chalk up your incomprehension of Robin's explanation as, you're either Drunk, or you're now too emotionally invested in this to save face and back out out gracefully by apologizing.

At this point, you're in a hole so deep, and refuse to see it, that if someone threw you a ladder, you'd start digging with it.

sunshinenbrick wrote: Thanks :D Yeah I really hope that dialogues between parties can be kept open so that they can mutually benefit each other. I know that sounds a bit soppy but I suppose (more movie taglines coming up) we do need to have some hope here... not easy I know but its that or dispair!

Psijonica wrote: Well reaper for one I'm female but in the world we live in everything is fairly androgynous eh?

i am not being stubborn, I am standing up for what I believe in. There is a difference. Dark0ne benefits from Pay-for-Mods. Either way it doesn't hurt him. Right now we are downloading every mod we can because I know that all the mods for Oblivion will soon be pay- for -mod, all the Morrowind mods will be Pay-for-mod...


THIS USED TO BE FREE AND FUN!!!! It will never be fun again, it will just become an expense. Now all these modders are going to cry about SOPA??? hahahaha You deserve SOPA now!

monkeyweather wrote: Thanks for keeping this whole thing civil to the best of your abilities, and for keeping everyone in the loop as much as you can.

SchwererGustav wrote: well i helped people to get their modded skyrim to run for 2 month in the forum after that i thought i payed back what i downloaded here.

and this is the only website i had my addblocker off, too(you know how every other site makes money).

I'm not rich and Psijonica isn't eather i guess so we take that little fun we have left in our lives,
freedom, creativity and helping other people thats what i thought was this side about, but now they sell out and take that last piece of choice that makes us burst out in anger.. can't you people understand this?

This deal will mark the beginning of the end off modding, the last bastion of freedom that was left...

Pestilenz wrote: Yeah the community paid for the servers, by either choosing to get premium either because they had money to spare, wanted to help or wanted the extra features or by "gob beware" using the site and downloading mods, I feel so abused shame one you Dark0ne.

sunshinenbrick wrote: I totally understand what you mean by paying for things through other means than money (creativity, support, non-financial contribution) however I do hope that sometimes it is best to take down things you don't agree with from within. This is to say that although I cannot speak for the site owner nor do I know, or ever talked to him, but he has stated his position and we should try give him some benefit of the doubt because there are things that can be safeguarded against.

Suppose time will tell but it is somewhat comforting to know that the players at hand here do see the value of the community here. Admittedly it might be money orientated, however we can have the chance to show them there is more to modding than that. Then maybe they will see that suffocating all aspects of the free community will stifle creativity. I hope. And we can start by using donation systems. But that's money I hear you say??? Yes but it is important HOW you give money and WHO you give it to.

HadToRegister wrote:

Psijonica
Well reaper for one I'm female but in the world we live in everything is fairly androgynous eh?

I'm glad that you and your wife, and two kids, and your paid for house are happy.

Psijonica
Dark0ne benefits from Pay-for-Mods

HE ONLY BENEFITS.......ONLY, if someone CHECKS THE BOX that says "Send 5% of the earning for this mod to the Nexus", there are also checkboxes to send 5% to the makers of NifSKope and Blender as well.
Why aren't you complaining about those two things possibly getting 5% whenever someone checks the box for them to receive 5% of the income?

If a modder DOESN'T check that box for The NEXUS, or NifSkope etc then the Nexus and NifSkope etc get NOTHING, ZERO, ZIP, ZILCH, NADA, NOTHING, is sent to the Nexus, NOTHING....
Do you UNDERSTAND IT YET?

The Nexus isn't getting a cut of any mods being sold on SteamWorks UNLESS THE MOD AUTHOR CHECKS THE BOX to let the Nexus have 5% of the sales as a "Thank You"

Psijonica
THIS USED TO BE FREE AND FUN!!!! It will never be fun again, it will just become an expense.

It's still "Free and Fun" (especially for YOU Ms. "Free Nexus Account" ), however, you're directing your anger at the wrong person

Tanniss wrote: actually he is getting money from the community unless he is independantly wealthy or paying his creditors with air he gets his money from ad's that we help support by not having ad block on and by the memberships that people pay for as well as donations from the community

Tanniss wrote: which can and will be used later on down the road to take away any credibility on darkones part if he decides to stop fence sitting and pick the side of being afraid free modding is going to disappear by saying hey why you bitching now when you had no problem taking donations from our (valves ) cut instead of the modders giving a cut to nexus for this site being such a great place to find tools and free mods

I am surprised that no one sees this because its buying him even if he or us dont think so because at the end of the day if you take money from those who are trying to take and run a monopoly no matter the small % given you are still silently supporting the endeavor they are trying to force down everyone elses throat

and mind you im not being a troll nor am i stupid and if some feel the need to toss insults towards me so be it bottom line is when you take money for something that you think is more than likely going to be inherently wrong that makes your arguments a little less weighty

Psijonica wrote: HadToRegister

Yes my wife and I are very happy. It is well known that I am a lesbian. I have never hid from that here or anywhere. Do you have something against the gay and lesbian community?

You keep on trying to goat me with your pathetic attempts in arguing with me but I have been ignoring you. You are a troll and your continued attempts into drawing me into a flame war will fail.

You failed :)

Reaper0021 wrote: See you made a good point and did it in such a way that doesn't speak of "Conspiracy Theories" running rampant. No your not stupid at all and you do make good points. The 'other' person on this thread is on an obvious witch hunt. Big difference. I shouldn't have to point that out to you.

Psijonica wrote: Thanks monkeyweather, it has not been easy to keep things civil especially when the owner of the site comes and trolls my post effectively giving permission for everybody else to do the same. Shame on him for that.

I read all his posts and his reddits and although he tries to pretend to pin Gabe down on the DRM issue he himself doesn't even make public his own position on Pay-for-Mods.

This is why I don't trust him. I deal with politicians for a living, I am well tuned to the BS station.

Reaper0021 wrote: NOBODY cares you are a Lesbian with a chip on her shoulder. Nobody cares about your sexual orientation. Period. None of us. Nobody has said anything except, after you felt the need to back-up your arguments with telling us how you own a home and your kids are responsible and your married and whatnot, all anybody has said was "Good for you and hope your happy. And my religious beliefs fly contrary to your chosen lifestyle...but do you hear me saying anything? No. Good. Nobody is going to be baited into a "Gay and Lesbian" tirade debate with you so you have yet even MORE to gripe about along with what you're already doing.

phantompally76 wrote: you're, not your.

Reaper0021 wrote: you're, not your.


It's late and i don't care. The point is made but ty anyway.

Kusumura wrote:

I don't think Psijonica "looks stupid" at all, Dark0ne.

Quite the opposite, actually.

And I also think that YOU are coming out of this looking dishonest, petty, unapologetic, and at the risk of upsetting you (which is not my intention), just a little sociopathic.

You can't shrug or laugh this off. This is a MUCH bigger deal than you're trying to make it out to be, and just because you refuse to admit there is a problem with your lack of disclosure and transparancy....that doesn't make the problem go away.

And like it or not, a LOT of people have a problem with this.
- From phantompally76

Oh, God. Please, let's not have this become #skyrimgate2015...

EDIT: Fixed up the quote.

HadToRegister wrote:

Psijonica
Yes my wife and I are very happy. It is well known that I am a lesbian. I have never hid from that here or anywhere. Do you have something against the gay and lesbian community?

No problem at all, I have gay and lesbian friends, and, as I said in my post.
[i'm glad that you and your wife, and two kids, and your paid for house are happy.]

Now, you've definitely got some MAJOR reading comprehension problems if you are somehow getting that I have a problem with the LGBT community with my comment.

At this point, I'll just chalk it up to you either have some type of reading comprehension problem, or are just belligerent and looking to fight about EVERYTHING.

Anyway, I'm completely fed up with you, because you aren't even participating in the discussion anymore, and instead are acting like a belligerent party-goer who has had a few too many drinks, and wants to try and turn EVERYTHING into a fight

Rullnick wrote: Your mistake is thinking that he can only be on ONE side of the issue, Either he's FOR paid mods or He's AGAINST them. When in reality he's neither, he's neutral because the paid mods aren't the deciding thing here.

He said he isn't a champion white-knight for free mods, and he said he isn't a money-hungry demon from hell. He just wants mods to be free and open when the mod creators want them to be. Why are you so goddamn narrow-sighted? If you read the post you would see you're exactly the kind of people he is talking about.

By the way, people disagreeing with you isn't "trolling". It's just you being unable to take f*#@ing criticism.

Reaper0021 wrote: I agree the whole "Lesbian" thing is this.....person just trying to bait us into a fight and make it look as if we have issues with her ilk. Don't be fooled into any type of debate. I'm going to go play some Attila at any rate online, so peace to you all. I'm done with this nightmare of a woman and her continued inability to basically 'comprehend' that which has been made clear time and time again.

RaskorGaming wrote: "Endorsements given: 279"

Oh, really?

iloveyoupurples wrote: Everyone has an opinion, here's mine. I agree with you about half way. The mod users, get the fair deal. We get free mods. We have a place to get them, a place to install them. A place to discuss it. I take issue on behalf of the authors. Nexus is a business. Nexus is owned by a person. Said person makes a nice bloated salary. Such is business. As a consumer I'm getting the best deal period. Free mods. We come here to get mods. We view adds. We pay for premium accounts so it doesn't take 30 years to download a mod. No big deal. These mod authors make mods. Robin makes a tidy profit because we come to get them. Mod authors are given nothing. Robin pays for xyz. Cool. Robin makes a bloated profit from the investment. Mod authors get nothing. We don't come to view the adds. Or add to his cooperate portfolio. We come for mods. He gets paid because of it. Mod authors get nothing. Blah blah blah he pays xyz. Cool. Is it suddenly non profit? I had no issue knowing all this before valve decided to sell mods off the backs of their authors. I take issue now because it's hypocritical for him to say anything considering we come here for free mods WHILE MOD AUTHORS GET NOTHING. Then raise the banner of MODZFREEFROEVARRRR etc. If I were you I'd have kept my mouth shut on my opinion. It's hypocritical. You profit off the mod authors just like valve is trying to. So I agree with Psijonica to a degree. Yeah, you made a good business decision making a website and shored up a tidy residual sum for yourself. Problem I have is you wave a flag as if you're non profit. Mod authors are getting shafted. Period. I wish I could afford to donate to every mod I use, sadly I can't. Still From now on, when I have an extra dollar on my meager salary I'm buying a good author a coffee. Sorry authors I should have decided to donate sooner.

Psijonica wrote:
75 mods have been hidden on the Nexus because the mod makers are scared that people are going to steal their assets, some people are talking about taking down any tips they've given out because people are going to steal them to make a profit. We're already seeing the lose part of the paywall when the community closed down and people are too paranoid to share their resources. We've already seen assets being stolen, lazy and unfinished mods being sold and one person putting out a free version with an annoying pop up.

The shadowscale armor is one item, clips with numerous races, you have to use the console to get it.
Chesko and Isoku used assets they had no right to use when they sold their mods and are now getting DMCA'd
Midas Magic put a annoying pop-up on the free version for a paid version that isn't anymore polished or improved.

Right now, literally this thread, is a example of the community getting split and damaged. Everyone is losing besides Valve and Bethesda, no one in this thread is winning under the current model.

@ HadToRegister
if you continue to pester me I will just have to report you. I am not even talking to you or even paying attention to what you are writing. Please leave me alone.

@ Reaper0021
i am not sure what your problem is. One post you are saying I am smart and the next you are accusing me of trying to bait you into an argument. Take it easy, you seem to be losing control of your self. if you are actually getting upset then the problem lies between your own ears. You posted that you were and adult in your 40's? No way. People in their 40's don't act like this. At this point you give me reason to ask that you please, please just leave me be. Ty.

No Endorsements, No Permissions, No Donations. 100% free mods 4-ever.

"The spirit of modding is sharing. In order to grow in quality rather than in quantity, modding has to be a labour of love, not a labour for money." - Emma

Reaper0021 wrote: iloveyoupurples now this is how you make a point. This post right here.

Reaper0021 wrote: In your past posts....you have been great. I said that and asked you "Why" you're all over the place right now/tonight? DON'T try to blame me for your woes or act as if I'm doing you harm. You've done that all on your own tonight. You deliberately played your "Lesbian" card in such a manner as to warrant caution cause you seem to be looking for a fight. You deliberately attempted to bait HadToRegister into a "do you have something against Lesbian/Gay's" argument. All here can see it and all here have said as much (about how you've maybe bee ndrinking tonight cause you say one thing then contradict yourself saying another without ANY thought of what you're saying".

Psijonica wrote: Ya so what. Leave me alone. I was just giving him a little taste of his own medicine.

What does that have to do with you? Right! Nothing. Now go pester someone else. You want to pay for mods, go ahead. I don't care about you. You are not even a modder. I have released mods, only one here but I have mods on other forums. so I am asking you politely...; if you are the adult that you claim then please respect my wishes and stop already. I am not talking to you any more. If you are the adult you claim to be then please act like it now.

Reaper0021 wrote: Yep far more of it than you. Sure it's stopped no sweat lay off of myself and HadToRegister. For GOOD.

Psijonica wrote: @ iloveyoupurples

You see, that is how this whole issue started. Donations is the problem. Once Bethesda saw that people were making many off of their product that had no choice but to protect themselves.

They gave us the CS (construction set) for free and allowed and trusted us to mod as a hobby. But we abused that trust and turned it into a business. And so now Big Daddy Bethesda is coming and punishing us by saying , "you want to sell your mods, fine. But now we control everything and we want our cut."

Greedy modders. You deserve this. I hope they steal your mods and take everything. Because of this the entire community spirit has be poisoned.

No Endorsements, No Permissions, No Donations. 100% free mods 4-ever.

"The spirit of modding is sharing. In order to grow in quality rather than in quantity, modding has to be a labour of love, not a labour for money." - Emma

hector530 wrote: you keep trying VERY hard to play the victim. "Dark0ne is trolling me!!!!" "im being bullied"

"i am not being stubborn, I am standing up for what I believe in."

yes you are, you will believe what you believe in no matter what is said and shown against it. the true beauty of a conspiracy theorist is that proof against the conspiracy is only proof of a conspiracy.

Wolvenlight wrote: @Psijonica

To be honest, I was never for the Grey Manes or the Battle Borns. I was never for the Imperials or the Stormcloaks. If Skyrim taught me anything, it's that people who tell you that you absolutely have to pick a side are wrong, and will bore you to death. In that order.

So when Dark0ne says he's neutral, I believe him. I've read his posts, he's never come out against pay4mods, he's only expressed concern about potential issues that could arise from them. He is not taking any modders cuts, and he's not forcing anyone to pay for him, he's merely opted into a voluntary system to help improve the site. If such a time comes when he decides to start charging for access to this site, or allowing mods to make their mods pay for only, then you will have evidence for your claims.

Claims you have made a lot of. You say he wants to be a champion for free mods, but he never claimed that. You state he's angry he didn't get a bigger cut of Valve's profits, but you have no evidence for this claim. You claim he is a troll merely because he pointed out an illogical inconsistency in your argument (in a minor, kind of sort of rude way, which I get and see it as the mistake it was, if only because you'd continue bringing it up.) You claim other people are trolling you when they merely disagree with you. You claim to have fought for this site and free modding, yet you aren't a contributor (neither am I, but I understand this place wouldn't be here without them.) You even claim to be standing up for what you believe in.

There is a difference between standing up for your beliefs and flinging accusations about without proper evidence. You want to question his motives? That's fine, I question the funds of scientific studies all the time, but I always read the study, take in the evidence, and mull it over to see if their are any actual flaws before accusing the study of being a shill for a corporate interest. Forgive me for saying so, but you sound like a religious doomsayer the way you talk. Or like you're a conservative who really hates anything to do with democrats.

If you apply the same argument to yourself as you have to others, then you have called people debating actual points with you "pathetic," just like the guy who "called you stupid." There is nothing troll about people merely disagreeing with you in the same tone you have disagreed with others. If you want to be taken seriously, then debate facts in a clear, respectful manner. If not, have fun with your free nexus account.

While it lasts. Or something.

x9fallen wrote: "This used to be free and fun". And what contributions have you made to the modding community?

Also, it was never free. Hosting files and allowing traffic to and from has a very real cost associated with it. If you don't like the price you have to pay (seeing an ad or two or seeing an option to go premium), don't pay it. See if you can find a community that allows file hosting/download with no cost that you can contribute nothing to. There isn't one. Which is why you'll stay here and continue to whine.

You've offered nothing of substance to the discussion. Your main complaints are that, although facts have been laid out, the author is still trying to deceive the community. You've also inferred the author has called you stupid twice, which is objectively false.

Reaper0021 wrote: Kudos given to Hector, Wolvenlight and x9fallen.

WightMage wrote: I'm totally quoting you on that. xP

iloveyoupurples wrote: <3 happy to help. I have always seen that as the glaring elephant in the room.

phantompally76 wrote: "And what contributions have you made to the modding community?"

THOUSANDS of hours of testing player mods, helping authors flesh out bugs, glitches, issues and incompatibilities. Offering suggestions to enhance and improve those mods. Discussing those mods with others, spreading knowledge about said mods to other users who may have otherwise never installed/endorsed them. Offering praise and encouragement (and endorsements) to mod authors who might have otherwise given up, and defending mod authors against self-entitled millenials on here who expect them to do whatever they want, when they want.

THAT is my contribution to this community. And whether I have donated one red cent to a single mod author or not, THAT makes me every bit as much a member of the modding community as you. So don't try to lord your premium membership over me or anyone else on here. We are equals.

And I bet that just burns you up...

Ramon1 wrote: While I don't put Dark0ne's words in doubt that all the proceedings will go directly into the Nexus, no matter how anybody tries to paint it, it's not going to sit well in a lot of people that Nexus is receiving money from Valve, which at this point, somehow has managed to turned itself overnight into something worse than all the EAs and UBIs of the world.

And the thing is, if you see beyond the face value of the Nexus receiving money from Valve, you will see a huge chunk of the same bile Valve has managed to inject the modding community, and the PC gaming community, with. They did it good, they struck where it mattered and regardless of monetary transactions, it's highly probably modding will never be the same, just remember how well Mr. Gabe managed to avoid Dark0ne's invitation to take an stance against eventually limiting modding to the workshop.

They are in for the greed of it and once they taste the goods, the easy money they are going to earn at the expense of modders, they won't stop until modders become official DLC and bugfixes contractors.

How the heck we came to witness stEAm basically attempting to ruin PC gaming forever, that is beyond me.

Psijonica wrote: Oh don't bother, that guy xfallen has no friends, no pics, no mods. I have plenty of mods out there on other sites and I have one small mod I made for a friend here. I have worked on many mods large and small I I have enjoyed myself over the years. ***I have made lots of friends over the years some of whom actually became real life friends so it is all good here.***

xfallen and reapper (who can'r stop talking about me on every other post LoL while he claims to be in his 30's and owns a house with childre hahaha) the truth is that these trolls are children because I don't know any adults who would behave like this.

Am I 100% right in everything I posted? No. Have I made some assumptions that are wrong? Yes, but overall I stand by my overall position.

Is Dark0ne supporting pay-for-mods, I think he does, will the nexus stay free, I think it will, is he playing both sides of the coin I think that is obvious.

I am actually giving up on this fight. I loved the modding community and it has given me lots of pleasure but I am leaving it for the same reason Wrye left modding. I am not comparing myself to Wrye but I knew him back in the day.

I think everyone should pay for mods. I hope it becomes the norm and that people become successful. I hope Dark0ne makes a lot of money from Valve. I can see SOPA passing into law within the next 5-10 years. I am done fighting. I give up. I don't care any more.

janishewski wrote: It's going to a pay system. You can accept that and move on, or not. Nobody cares. And if you pirate pay mods, I hope you are prosecuted.

Psijonica wrote: WTF???
Is something wrong with you? Did you take you medication tonight?

No one has ever mentioned anything about pirating mods in this post. Where do you get off on making wild accusation like that. Why would you wish such a horrible thing to someone?

Should I hope you rob a bank and get arrested?

*sigh*

x9fallen wrote: @ phantompally76 Well, I wasn't replying to you. It sounds like you have made significant contributions to the modding community. Also, I fully acknowledge my premium is nothing in terms of contributing to the community. Hell, I fully admit I don't contribute much to the modding community at present. I certainly wouldn't "lord" anything over someone. My inquiry was regarding Psjonica's contribution to the modding community as the statement saying "used to be fun and free" implies that they are a contributor.

I look at it this way: if I'm consuming content more than I am contributing to content, I am not in a position to complain and rant about the content.

digitaltrucker wrote: I disagree, without people to use the mods there would be no reason to form a community around the mods. A mod user is every bit an important part of the community as a mod author. Neither side is more or less entitled than the other.

Psijonica wrote: I have nothing to prove to YOU. Who are you? I need to answer to you? LoL You are nothing to me. You mean absolutely nothing to me so I don't have to prove anything to you.

I have friends here. I have worked and helped people make their mods mods and I have released mods all over the internet. Who cares. I am a person. I AM A PERSON! Just like you.

What have you done? Oh right... nothing. Unbelievable that you sit there and judge me... should I do the same to you now?

Just is just silly...

x9fallen wrote: Psijonica, you seem to be the one acting childish in this thread. Your angry and you're ranting on like an angst-filled teen. Yes, I'm not very active on the forums and haven't done any modding, that is part of the reason I'm not shouting at Nexus staff or modders who want to be paid for their work.

You, as someone who seems to only be able to shout, should be required to prove your contributions if you're going to shout. I don't believe you're able to speak on behalf of the modders as you seem to be trying to do.

Also, I can't believe your stance on no donations is a popular one amongst modders. I believe they'll take a stand against pay-for-mods but I find it hard to imagine that they would stand against optional donations. That seems silly

Psijonica wrote: I don't care what you believe.

JetBoom21 wrote: Dude come on Psijonica, you sound like a someone who can't get over people calling him stupid online, what's up with the way you type, it looks like you're a old man stuck in a child mind.

x9fallen wrote: You'd have to ask the author of Interesting NPCs or Chesko about my contributions. I won't do that here.

derek6688 wrote: Just let her win.

Aegrus wrote: She's female, and she's been accusing people of being sexist or anti LGBT all day for getting that wrong.

Well for the sake of transparency, has Dark0ne released the stats on how many premium member Nexus has? If the site requires 500K of revenue to run, and the site is still running, then I'm guessing that Dark0ne is bringing in AT LEAST 500K per year and probably more.

Dark0ne says that only 75 mods have gone in the last 2 days and Nexus still has over 40K mods on the site. However, if the mods can only be on Steam exclusively, whilst charging for the mod, and if Nexus is credited 5% of the mod's price only if the mod is "monetized", then it serves in Darkones interest to have all the mods leave Nexus and be monetized on Workshop.

We have 40K mods remaining as free, but what will happen by next year, 30K? And the year after that, 20K? Eventually, all mods will move to a monetized system on Steam, whist Dark0ne is receiving 5% of 40K mod revenues, all the while, having no reason to host this site anymore, as all the mods have gone. THAT'S a Plus and a Plus. Time to retire on an island and drink margaritas, right Dark0ne? I don't blame you....my greed would probably take me in the same direction.